P2P financial statements

Transparency. The figures are taken from the accounts published by each company, and the analyses are written partly with the help of artificial intelligence. Despite our checks, an error is still possible: if in doubt, the original PDF, downloadable on each row, prevails.

Who is rated? The types of financial statements

The table mixes two families of accounts that do not do the same business. Before reading a score, check what type of company it is: each type has its own rules.

🖥️ Platforms: 2 cases

  • Marketplace23 platforms

    It connects investors and lenders, with no loans on its balance sheet: investors' money is off balance sheet or only passes through. Rated with the platform grid (4 criteria).

    Examples: Mintos, PeerBerry, ViaInvest, Twino, Nectaro

  • Assets on balance sheet6 platforms

    It has loans on its balance sheet or must itself repay investors when a borrower does not pay. It is rated like a lending company (5 criteria, loan losses included).

    Examples: Swaper, Modena, Maclear, Fintown, Devon

🏦 Lending companies: 4 cases

  • Lender149 companies

    Credit company that lends to individuals or businesses and sells its loans on the platforms. Rated on the 5 criteria.

    Examples: Creditstar, Wandoo Finance, Fincard

  • Funding vehicle10 companies

    Company that borrows on a platform to finance the lenders of its group or of its partners. Same rating as a lender: loan losses NP = 0/5 if they are not published.

    Examples: Mintos Finance, SW Finance (Swaper subsidiary), Gatelink (Lendermarket)

  • Holding5 companies

    Parent company of a group of lenders: its risk depends on its subsidiaries. Note: its financial statements may be consolidated (the whole group) or not (the holding alone); this is stated in the analysis. Consolidated accounts: the group's losses are rated (NP = 0/5 if missing). Stand-alone accounts: loan losses not applicable ("—"), the criterion is removed.

    Examples: Mintos Holdings, FinWind LT, Sakari Ventures (Modena group)

  • Company borrowing for its own assets5 companies

    Non-financial company that borrows on a platform to finance its own business: forestry, real estate, software. It does not lend: loan losses not applicable ("—"), criterion removed.

    Examples: Latvian Forest Development Fund, Lithome (real estate), Linqo (software)

Rating lending companies: how the score out of 5 is calculated

A lending company's score is based on 5 criteria, each scored from 0 to 5, then weighted according to its importance. There is no penalty: serious auditor warnings weigh directly on the "Reliability of accounts" criterion.

20%
25%
25%
10%
20%
Profitability
Equity
Loan losses
Cash
Reliability of accounts
1. Profitability20%

Does the company make money with what it owns?

Net profit ÷ average assets for the year (ROA), over 2 years

+ Why this criterion and its scale

A profitable company strengthens its equity every year and can absorb loan losses without putting investors at risk. A loss-making company eats into its reserves.

Profit is compared with total assets, i.e. with all the loans financed, including those funded with investors' money. The ROE used in V1 has been removed: it skyrockets when equity is tiny (106% at a lender with almost no capital) and then gives a misleading picture.

Profit is earned throughout the year, so it is compared with the average assets of the year, i.e. the average of assets at the start and at the end. Otherwise, a fast-growing lender would look less profitable than it really is.

We also look at the previous year: an isolated loss after a profitable year scores 0.5/5, two losses in a row score 0. A profit that follows a loss, or whose previous year is not available, is capped at 4/5 until profitability is confirmed over 2 years.

Its weight is 20%: a profitable lender absorbs its loan losses with its profits, a loss-making lender eats into its equity.

  • 10% or more5/5
  • 7.5 to 10%4.5/5
  • 5 to 7.5%4/5
  • cap: profit after a loss, or previous year not available4/5
  • 3 to 5%3/5
  • 1.5 to 3%2/5
  • 0 to 1.5%1/5
  • isolated loss, after a profitable year0.5/5
  • losses 2 years in a row0/5
2. Equity25%

What share of the balance sheet is financed by the shareholders?

Equity ÷ total assets

+ Why this criterion and its scale

Equity is the money contributed and left in the company by its shareholders. When loans are not repaid, this cushion absorbs the losses first, before investors.

With 25% equity, the company can lose a quarter of its assets before its creditors are hit. This ratio replaces V1's "Debt ÷ equity": same idea, but easier to read (from 0 to 100%).

  • 25% or more5/5
  • 20 to 25%4/5
  • 15 to 20%3/5
  • 10 to 15%2/5
  • 5 to 10%1/5
  • 0 to 5%0.5/5
  • negative or zero0/5
3. Loan losses25%

What share of revenue is lost on loans that are not repaid?

Credit losses for the year ÷ revenue (cost of risk)

+ Why this criterion and its scale

A lender's business is to lend and get repaid. Every year, it writes off ("impairment") the loans it no longer expects to recover, or sells them at a loss to debt collection companies: this is the best indicator of the quality of its customers.

Compared with revenue, this cost shows what share of income is eaten up by bad debts. For consumer credit, 10 to 25% is common. Above 35%, the model becomes fragile. New in V2: this criterion did not exist.

If the losses do not appear in the accounts, there are two cases. "NP" (not published) when the company lends (lender, funding vehicle, holding with consolidated accounts): the information should be published, so the criterion scores 0/5. "—" (not applicable) when the company does not lend itself (holding with stand-alone accounts, company borrowing for its own assets): the criterion is removed and the score is calculated on the other criteria, then brought back to a scale of 5.

  • 10% or less5/5
  • 10 to 15%4/5
  • 15 to 25%3/5
  • 25 to 35%2/5
  • 35 to 45%1/5
  • more than 45%, or NP (not published: the company lends but does not publish its losses)0/5
4. Cash10%

Does the company have money available to meet its payments?

Cash ÷ total debt

+ Why this criterion and its scale

Cash is the money available right away to make repayments, including those owed to investors. Too little cash, and the slightest setback turns into late payments.

Its weight stays low (10%), because a lender deliberately keeps little idle money: it lends it. A low level is not a flaw in itself; a near-zero level is a warning sign.

  • 20% or more5/5
  • 15 to 20%4/5
  • 10 to 15%3/5
  • 5 to 10%2/5
  • 2 to 5%1/5
  • 1 to 2%0.5/5
  • less than 1%0/5
5. Reliability of accounts20%

Can the published figures be trusted?

Auditor's opinion, accounting standards (IFRS or local) and size of the audit firm

+ Why this criterion and its scale

All the other criteria rely on the published figures. Accounts checked by an independent audit firm, with a signed report, are worth much more than a table prepared by the company itself.

We read the audit report ourselves: the word "Audited" on a platform's website is not enough, and the auditor's qualifications are taken into account. New in V2: this criterion did not exist.

An unqualified audit is worth more when the accounts follow the international IFRS standards (more detailed, comparable from one country to another) and when the auditor belongs to one of the ten major networks (KPMG, PwC, EY, Deloitte, BDO, RSM, Grant Thornton, Mazars, Baker Tilly, Crowe).

Serious warnings from the auditor bring this criterion down to 0: refusal to certify, adverse opinion, doubt about the company's ability to continue as a going concern, or a breached commitment to lenders ("covenant"). Its weight is 20% (25% in the first draft of V2, considered too heavy).

  • unqualified, IFRS standards, major firm5/5
  • unqualified, IFRS and small firm, or local standards and major firm4/5
  • unqualified, local standards, small firm3/5
  • qualified, limited review only, or accounts restated afterwards or contradictory2/5
  • full unaudited accounts1/5
  • extract, presentation, management report0.5/5
  • refusal, adverse opinion, going-concern doubt, breached covenant, audit report not available, nothing published0/5

Real example: Creditstar Group, 2025 accounts (group of Monefit SmartSaver and Lendermarket)

Profitability
2/5 × 20% = 0.4
Equity
3/5 × 25% = 0.75
Loan losses
4/5 × 25% = 1.0
Cash
3/5 × 10% = 0.3
Reliability
5/5 × 20% = 1.0
The score is the sum of the contributions. A special situation is flagged 🚨 in its analysis: its debt ratio is close to the limit set by its lenders.3.5 / 5

Rating platforms: how the score out of 5 is calculated

A platform that only connects investors and lenders does not lend itself, so it has no bad debts of its own. Its main risk is running out of money to operate. If it shuts down, investors are left alone to monitor and recover their loans. A marketplace is therefore rated on 4 criteria focused on its ability to last: equity 30%, profitability 25%, cash 25%, reliability 20%. A platform with assets on its balance sheet is rated like a lending company (see below).

25%
30%
25%
20%
Profitability
Equity
Cash
Reliability of accounts
1. Profitability25%

Does the platform make money from its business?

Net profit ÷ revenue (net margin), over 2 years

+ Why this criterion and its scale

A platform owns few assets of its own: comparing its profit with its assets says little. The net margin shows whether its model works, i.e. whether fees cover salaries, IT and marketing.

A profitable platform does not need to raise money to keep going. A loss-making platform depends on its shareholders: most young platforms are in this situation.

As for lending companies, we also look at the previous year: an isolated loss after a profitable year scores 0.5/5, two losses in a row score 0, and a profit that follows a loss, or whose previous year is not available, is capped at 4/5 until profitability is confirmed over 2 years.

  • 20% or more5/5
  • 15 to 20%4.5/5
  • 10 to 15%4/5
  • cap: profit after a loss, or previous year not available4/5
  • 5 to 10%3/5
  • 2 to 5%2/5
  • 0 to 2%1/5
  • isolated loss, after a profitable year0.5/5
  • losses 2 years in a row0/5
2. Equity30%

Have the shareholders left enough money to absorb a hard blow?

Equity ÷ operating expenses for the year

+ Why this criterion and its scale

A platform's balance sheet sometimes contains investors' money in transit, or loans it holds on their behalf. Comparing its equity with its assets would penalise it for no reason. So we compare it with the cost of one year of operation.

This follows the logic of the European crowdfunding regulation (ECSP): an authorised platform must hold safeguards (equity or insurance) equal to at least a quarter of its fixed costs of the previous year. This minimum corresponds to 2/5.

  • 100% or more (one year of expenses)5/5
  • 75 to 100%4/5
  • 50 to 75%3/5
  • 25 to 50% (European minimum)2/5
  • less than 25%1/5
  • zero or negative0/5
3. Cash25%

How many months can the platform last without new income?

Cash ÷ monthly operating expenses

+ Why this criterion and its scale

If investors pull out or partner lenders slow down, fees drop immediately, but salaries and IT still have to be paid. Cash tells you how long the platform can hold out.

Only the platform's own cash counts: investors' money passing through its accounts, waiting to be invested, is excluded.

This is a key criterion for investors: a platform that shuts down leaves its customers to handle the recovery of their loans on their own.

  • 12 months or more5/5
  • 6 to 12 months4/5
  • 3 to 6 months3/5
  • 2 to 3 months2/5
  • 1 to 2 months1/5
  • 15 days to 1 month0.5/5
  • less than 15 days0/5
4. Reliability of accounts20%

Can the published figures be trusted?

Auditor's opinion, accounting standards and size of the audit firm

+ Why this criterion and its scale

Same scale and same warnings as for a lending company: refusal to certify, adverse opinion, going-concern doubt or breached covenant bring this criterion down to 0.

  • unqualified, IFRS standards, major firm5/5
  • unqualified, IFRS and small firm, or local standards and major firm4/5
  • unqualified, local standards, small firm3/5
  • qualified, limited review only, or accounts restated afterwards or contradictory2/5
  • full unaudited accounts1/5
  • extract, presentation, management report0.5/5
  • serious auditor warning, audit report not available, nothing published0/5

Real example: ViaInvest, 2025 accounts of the company operating the platform

Profitability
4/5 × 25% = 1.0
Equity
5/5 × 30% = 1.5
Cash
3/5 × 25% = 0.75
Reliability
4/5 × 20% = 0.8
The score is the sum of the contributions: a profitable and well-capitalised platform, but with about 4 months of expenses in cash.4.1 / 5

Operating expenses: what it costs to run the platform for the year (salaries, IT, marketing, rent, fees, depreciation), excluding financial expenses and tax. They are read in the income statement.

Platforms with assets on their balance sheet, rated like a lending company

  • The platform carries the credit risk itself

    When a platform has loans on its balance sheet or must itself repay investors if a borrower does not pay, it carries the credit risk like a lender. It is then rated with the lending company grid, loan losses included, on its balance sheet as published: Bienprêter, Swaper, Modena, Maclear and Fintown.

  • The platform belongs to a group of lenders

    The accounts of the platform alone are rated with the platform grid. The group's risk is shown by the rating of its lending company, calculated on its consolidated accounts (for example Creditstar for Lendermarket, Fincard for Twino).

Rules common to both ratings

What if the financial statements are not published?

Until 31 October of the following year

The company keeps the score of its last published financial statements. Accounts are usually filed before the end of June or the end of July: this leaves a 3-month margin.

After 31 October: 0/5

Missing financial statements are not normal. The line "Financial statements not available" appears when you filter the company or its platform, and the score drops to 0 until publication.

The analysis of each financial statement

By clicking on a row of the table, you open a short analysis of the financial statements, written with the help of AI and proofread (in French). It always follows the same outline:

  1. 1

    🔍 Key figures of the financial statements

    Type of accounts, auditor, revenue, profit, assets and equity, in rounded millions of euros.

  2. 2

    ✅ The rather positive points

    2 or 3 strengths, with figures.

  3. 3

    ⚠️ The rather negative points

    2 or 3 weaknesses, with figures.

  4. 4

    🚨 Special situation to highlight

    Only if one of the cases listed below is found in the accounts.

  5. 5

    💡 Opinion

    In one or two sentences, and what to watch in the next financial statements.

🚨 The special situations flagged in the analysis

These situations do not change the score: it is still calculated on the 5 criteria. But they are worth knowing before investing, so they are highlighted in the analysis.

  • 🚨 The auditor resigns or is not reappointed without explanation

    Change of auditor during the engagement, or engagement interrupted: often a sign of disagreement over the accounts.

  • 🚨 Only an extract of the accounts

    Presentation, management report or 2-page balance sheet without notes: impossible to check the figures in detail.

  • 🚨 Large loans to shareholders or related companies

    Amounts lent to the owners or to their other companies exceeding 50% of equity: the money can leave the group.

  • 🚨 Restated prior-year accounts

    Figures already published have been significantly changed (restatement).

  • 🚨 Losses two years in a row

    An isolated loss can be explained; two consecutive losses show a model that does not work yet. This is the only situation in this list already counted in the score: profitability then scores 0.

  • 🚨 Equity halved in one year

    Equity down by more than 50% over one financial year, whatever the cause (losses, dividends, share buyback).

  • 🚨 Debt ratio close to the limit set by lenders

    Less than 10% headroom before a covenant limit (for example net debt of 4.86 times equity for a maximum of 5): a breach would allow lenders to demand immediate repayment.

  • 🚨 Dividends higher than the year's profit

    Shareholders pay themselves more than the company earned: the safety cushion gets thinner.

(Fictitious) example in an analysis

🚨 Special situation to highlight

- The company lent €4.2M to another company owned by its main shareholder, i.e. 70% of its equity. If this loan is not repaid, a large part of the safety cushion disappears.

Our reading rules

So that every score can be checked, here is how we read the accounts. Each financial statement is read in the official document published by the company, its platform, a registry or a stock exchange.

  • Missing data = 0

    If a figure or the audit report is not available, including when the published document is incomplete, the criterion concerned scores 0. The analysis says so, and we ask the platform for the full document. The score is reviewed as soon as it is published.

  • Doubt about the company's survival

    We count the warning when the auditor reports a remaining uncertainty about the company's ability to continue as a going concern, whether in a "material uncertainty" section or in an emphasis-of-matter paragraph describing it. A reference to a situation already resolved does not count.

  • Commitment to lenders (covenant)

    The warning is counted only if the accounts acknowledge that a commitment has been breached. A narrow headroom before the limit is flagged 🚨 in the analysis, with no effect on the score.

  • Credit losses

    Impairment charge on loans for the year, plus losses on receivables sold, as published. Gains on receivables taken off the balance sheet are never deducted. A net release of provisions counts as 0% loan losses.

  • Revenue

    All gross income from the business: interest, fees and other income (insurance commissions, collection fees…), always included, before interest expenses and credit losses.

  • Companies that do not lend

    Holdings with stand-alone accounts and companies borrowing for their own assets: the "Loan losses" criterion is not applicable ("—"), and the score is calculated on the other criteria. A company that lends without publishing its credit losses gets "NP" (not published) and 0/5 on this criterion.

  • Operating expenses of a platform

    Salaries, IT, marketing, rent, fees and depreciation for the year, read in the income statement, excluding financial expenses and tax. If the income statement is not published, the platform's Equity and Cash criteria score 0.

  • Verified audit

    We read the auditor's signed report: the word "audited" on a platform's website is not enough.

What changes between V1 and V2

V1 · May to November 2026V2 · since 13 November 2026
Net margin (20%)Removed for lenders, kept for platforms
ROA (20%)Profitability (20%): average assets of the year and previous year taken into account
ROE (20%)Removed: misleading when equity is low
Debt ÷ equity (20%)Equity ÷ assets (25%)
Cash ÷ debt (20%)Cash (10%)
—Loan losses (25%), new
—Reliability of accounts (20%), new
3 profiles (Balanced, Safety, Performance)A single score
Auditor warnings not taken into accountReliability at 0 in case of a serious auditor warning
Missing financial statements: no scoreMissing financial statements after 31 October of the following year: 0/5
Analysis of variable lengthShort analysis with the same outline, special situations flagged 🚨
Platforms rated like lendersDedicated grid for platforms: 4 criteria (equity 30%, profitability and cash 25%, reliability 20%), no loan losses

What the rating does not measure

Regulation, buyback guarantee, group guarantee, interest rates offered and the platform's track record are not part of the financial statements. They are assessed in the P2P comparison, where the financial statement score feeds the "Lender strength" and "Platform strength" sections.

Add a comment

A question or your own experience to share? Leave a comment: I reply personally.

A free account is all you need to comment: one-click sign-in with Google, or by email.

Create an account